If I was a Jewish elder in the council considering what part of the oral tradition would be finally penned, I would have had serious issues with a whole lot of Genesis. It is one thing to retell a story over a lingering campfire with kids sticking branches with skewered marshmallows or while licking lamb chop juices off one’s finger with the sacrifice fire slowly dying out. It is quite another thing to commit a story into a parchment. You finalize things when you write it down. There is no chance for revisions, no space for differing editions. There is hardly any margins for error because there is a finality to writing, and that sense of finality is often mistaken as fatality. What is written is absolutely true. What is spoken is never certain.
And what is written has rigid longevity, its rigidity being part of its longevity. Once a thing is written, it is going to be told in the exact same manner thousands of years into the future.
Those Jewish elders who translated the oral Genesis into a written Genesis probably had a greater understanding of longevity than we do today. Because they had a more affectionate memory of the past. Today, we have longer human history to look back to but our connections to previous generations are flimsy and have no real emotional pull. The names of even our personal ancestors only go back to the second generation at most. Anyone remember their great-great grandparent? Past history feels like a story of others, and so the future also feels like stories about others.
Ancient people had personal connections to the past. Their very names held the personal connections to the past as the names of their great ancestors were woven into their own names. With such connections to the past, the elders knew the future also was theirs too. They felt great responsibility to their descendents because they had great respect for their elders.
In one level, this is the point of Genesis, that all of human history is really family history. Genesis doesn’t linger greatly on any individual. Many chapters fast forward thousands of years. Like a time lapse of the universe birth and growth, it is meant to help us recognize the presentness of the past. This crunching of generations did not dismiss the lives of the individuals. Actually, it lifted the life of the individuals. Individual actions resonated down generations. Adam dared to go against God, and now all of humanity has to suffer the discrepancy of labor and the paucity of fruit. Abraham’s willingness to leave his father to head out west was the start of a nation that still occupies pretty much the same land Abraham went west to claim.
The Jewish elders knew that, so they selected the stories with great care and much prayer. They were listening for God’s instructions by respectful listening to each other. With that much pressure, then, I would have raised many concerns. Around the rickety table and the waning candle light, I would have recommended heavy editing before being sent out to the press. I imagine:
“I think,” I advise, “the part of Abraham lying and basically willing to let another man make a cuckold of him doesn’t have to be mentioned, and for sure not two times, and definitely don’t have Isaac do the same spineless thing. Why make our ancestors such pricks, sorry to say that word, but that is what those stories make them look like. So let’s just scratch that.”
“We’ve got to tell it as it is!” The youngest of the elder, which is not the same thing as saying young but practicing that uncompromising youthful idealism, exclaims by banging on the table.
At the end, most of the council agrees to keep such unflattering stories.
“Will keep it. Let us remember, we are reporters, not editor?” the moderator instructs to all but looks at me.
“Yeah, well reporters edit too. And I can let that go, the cuckolding. But not Cain getting away with murder! Can kills Abel, the first murder, and gets God’s protection?!! That is terrible. Because that is just going to encourage murderers. You kill and you don’t shed a single tear of regret but don’t worry God is going to protect your life. A murderer must be executed. Letting murderers go scot free is the ruin of a society. You let one go, before you know it thousand will demand the same protection for their crime! I can already see it. Some loose descendent of ours arguing against execution by producing this story and saying you see God didn’t execute, so we can’t either. That society is headed for anarchy!”
“You have a great point.” the moderator butters me us before another rejection of my sound advice, “but if we take that out, then we are just going to pretend that Cain and Abel did exist at all?”
“Why not! Let’s just skip it. No one will know. Adam right into Seth.”
“Sam, what does the Spirit of God say to you?”
A long pause and I really use that pause to listen. “Okay. Keep it.”
“Any more suggestions?”
“Okay, what about the whole Rachel and Leah pimping their slaves to Jacob to steal the attention of Jacob, and the names of the twelve fathers of our tribes simply being a way for Rachel and Leah to slap each other with their sons -- He will be Asher because I am happy while you are not. Can we just bring down the notch a bit? Even soap operas don’t get that sleazy! Our founding fathers being nothing less than product of a dysfunctional family just isn’t going to stir a lot of ancestor honoring.”
“But Sam,” I imagine the moderator being wise and so having a beard down to his ankle, and snowy white, like Gandalf, “that is what is so strangely beautiful about our story. It really isn’t about us. It isn’t about how great we Jews are. If we were ever to fall into that stupid mistake, it would be the death of us. It isn’t about us. It is about God, God’s faithfulness to Abraham, to Isaac, to Jacob, and then to Joseph even in Egypt and far from the promised land. It is about this amazing God that is intimate with us. I hear this story and true, I have to put my kids to bed before I can finish some of them. And God seems barbaric at times, like Bel or Dan these gods of the Canaanites. Yet God’s voice breaks through, doesn’t it? It shatters anything we expected of any other gods. Truly all these stories about our ancestors were not about them at all. All of our stories is really about God. And if God is the main character, then there isn’t a thing we can change. If we take our Cain, then it also removes that important character of God, His great mercy.”
“Well, yes, I see that. I see that. The more I read it, the more I see it….Okay let’s go with it.”
“Well then. Let’s finish this up. I want to make it back home before sunset. Any other suggestions.”
The moderator is about to close the meeting with a prayer but I think I would have blurted out, “Well, that thing about sacrificing the son, that is just too scary!”